“…received an innumerable quantity of exact replies concerning matters about which I had not asked.” Leo Tolstoy on what invariably happened when he asked scientists about the meaning of life
Right now, this second, an old man is exhaling his last breath. Elsewhere, two young lovers exchange their first kiss. Farther afield, two asteroids silently collide. Sunrise comes to a planet orbiting a neighboring star. This very second, a supernova detonates in a faraway galaxy.
Quantum physics assumes that the laws of nature are not deterministic and this is certainly good news for free will. Already the philosopher Immanuel Kant remarked in his Critique of Pure Reason (1781) that freedom is opposed to the deterministic natural law of cause and effect characteristic of classical physics.
This week on Big Questions Online, we invite you to vote for your favorite discussions. Some essays drew lots of comments and others are e-mailed often, but we want to hear from you.
What is your favorite Big Questions discussion and why? Tell us in the comments section. We'll keep track of your votes and tell you next week!
Not in any direct way. That is, it doesn’t provide an argument for the existence of God. But it does so indirectly, by providing an argument against the philosophy called materialism (or “physicalism”), which is the main intellectual opponent of belief in God in today’s world.